The Roman Catholic Diocese of BrooklynAbout the DioceseOur BishopsOur ParishesOur MinistriesCatholic EducationCatholic CharitiesThe Tablet
DonateHomeVocationsHuman ResourcesDevelopmentDonate
he Annulment Process
he Annulment Process
Myth Two
Myth Three
Myth Four
Myth Five
Myth Six
Myth Seven
Myth Eigth
Myth Nine
Myth Ten

Myth No. 4:
"Annulments take too long"

Some people imagine that getting an annulment is like taking care of a decaying tooth: something unpleasant you can put off a while, confident the dentist will squeeze you in if it acts up just before your vacation. An ex-spouse is a human being, not a toothache. Annulment of marriage is more like major surgery than a dental extraction. It should not be put off; it cannot be rushed.

Once accepted, a case should be completed within a year, according to the law. Six months more can be anticipated for the required review or for an appeal. The law does not say it has to take that long; but neither can it guarantee that it will not. Nor is there any entitlement to an annulment: the process , yes, but not a pre-determined result. Best advice? Plan ahead. The decision to begin an annulment process is one of the most momentous steps in a person's life. What he or she will learn from it, if properly disposed and motivated, can, and probably will, influence every important decision in the future.

To illustrate time and cost in an annulment process, I offer a medical analogy. An experienced surgeon will not operate before an initial examination of the patient, an investigation of family and medical histories and probably some preliminary tests. The patient must be able bodily to sustain not only the surgery, but also the emotional and physical rigors of recovery. Assuming a healthy patient, the operation may proceed routinely. Results, however, may not be immediately apparent or at all like anticipated. Recuperation could take longer. Other physicians might have to be consulted. A second opinion might lead to a second operation. Throughout the process, conditions at the hospital, the health and skill of medical personnel, and circumstances in the life of the patient will all affect the outcome. Sometimes discoveries about a patient's condition are made during or after surgery. More treatment or a different kind of treatment may be indicated. Plans will undoubtedly be affected.

Whatever the immediate or ultimate outcome for the patient, doctors and caregivers will be entitled to just remuneration, assuming procedures followed professional standards and contractual norms. An annulment need not produce such apprehension as surgery, but three stages - like preparation, operation and recuperation - can be identified.

The time before the court hearing is a very sober period of soul-searching. In this preparatory stage, parties are asked to write their family and personal histories, followed by the story of their relationship. This takes time. Important discoveries are often made during this period that may produce new insights or inspire deeper reflection.

At the court hearing, the second stage, the petitioner may discover concerns to be looked into before another marriage. Sometimes a longer "recuperation" may be required and the Tribunal might suggest or even mandate some professional counseling.

After every affirmative court decision, a third stage, comparable to a "second opinion" or evaluation, takes place in an appellate court. This is one reason diocesan law prohibits even "penciling in" a church wedding date on a parish calendar until the entire process is over, that is, when the petitioner has the final annulment decree in hand. No amount of money or attempts at string pulling can assure the exact outcome of any operation or the speed of the recovery. No more than the preparation, operation and recuperation stages of surgery, can annulment procedures be bought, sold or hurried.